2017 Cigar of the Year-A Compendium of Internet Blogs

Below is a table with a list of the 2017 Cigar of the Year selections by various Internet blogs. While we don’t review cigars except for our own single Cigar Intel Cigar of the Year published in January, we certainly keep track of the selections. See below and enjoy. You can sort by cigar name, ranking, etc. to do your own comparison of the cigars selected by various sources.

You can check out our compendium of 2017 Cigar of the Year selections by various cigar magazines HERE. <- FIX THIS!!!!!!

The various Internet blogs have a much broader selection of cigars than most of the magazines. Check out their selections below from Halfwheel, Cigar Dojo, Cigar Coop, Cigar Federation, and Blind Man’s Puff.


RankingHalfWheel Top 25 Cigars 2017Cigar Dojo 2017 Cigar of the Year AwardsCigar Coop 2016 Cigar of the YearCigar Federation Top 25 of 2017Blind Man's Puff Top 25 Cigars of the Year - 2017
1Quesada Reserva Privada Barber Pole Corona GordaUndercrown Sun GrownEIROA The First 20 Years Colorado 50 x 5 by C.L.E. Cigar CompanyMuestra De Saka NacatamaleFoundation The Wise Man Maduro
2Davidoff Winston Churchill The Late Hour RobustoFoundation Cigar The Wise Man MaduroLa Aurora 107 Cosecha 2006 Corona Gorda EspecialAtabey MisticosDunbarton Tobacco and Trust Todos Las Dias
3La Flor Dominicana TCFKA "M" Collector's Edition 2016Avo Syncro South America RitmoGaaja Maduro Torpedo by Bombay TabakEl Guenuense MaduroCrowned Heads Las Calaveras Edicion Limitada 2017
4CAO Amazon AnacondaSouthern Draw Cigars Jacobs LadderCrux Limitada Show Exclusive 2016BLK WKS Boondock SaintDrew Estate FSG
5Davidoff Ambassador Fine Cigars 20th AnniversaryLa Gloria Cubana Coleccion Reserva601 La Bomba Warhead III by Espinosa CigarsMuestra De Saka ExclusivoMombacho Cosecha 2012
6Tatuaje The MichaelTatuaje NegociantTodos Las Dias Double Wide Belicoso by Dunbarton Tobacco & TrustBlack Label Trading Company Bishop's BlendCornelius & Anthony Senor Esugars
7VegaFina Robusto Extra Pigtail Anejado 7 AnosAsylum 13 Medulla OblongataGuardian of the Farm RamboTatuaje Havana Cazadores Broadleaf CollectionTatuaje Cojonuda 2003 Reserva Broadleaf
8Illusione Cigares Prive Corojo Prensado SuaveVilliger La Flor De YnclanThe Wise Man (El Gueguense) Maduro Robusto by Foundation Cigar CompanySouthern Draw Jacob's Ladder ToroCaldwell Hit & Run
9The T. Short ChurchillCaldwell All Out KingsHoyo La Amistad (Gold) RothschildHighclere Castle ToroDunbarton Tobacco and Trust Muestra de Saka Nacatamale
10Muestra De Saka ExclusivoProtocol ThemisDavidoff - The Master Selection 2016Mombacho Cosecha 2012Caldwell All Out Kings
11Aging Room Quattro F55M Maduro ConcertoN/ASaga Short Tales Tomo II-Tales of the Land: Cotui by De Los Reyes CigarsTodos Las Dias Half ChurchillCrowned Heads Four Kicks Maduro
12Eiroa The First 20 Years Colorado 50 x 5Cornelius & Anthony Aerial RobustoPappy Van Winkle Tradition ToroTatuaje Negociant
13Rocky Patel Vintage 2006 San Andreas RobustoRoMa Craft Tobac Wunder|Lust Robusto (2017)All Out Kings SmashSouthern Draw Rose of Sharon
14Crux Limitada Show Exclusive 2016Mombacho Cosecha 2012Fratello Oro RobustoRoMaCraft Wunder|Lust
15Tatuaje Tattoo NeedlesDavidoff Nicaragua 6 x 60Black Label Trading Company Morphine LanceroH. Upmann AJ Fernandez
16Blind Man's Bluff Connecticut RobustoPadron 1926 Serie No. 90 MaduroProtocol Themis ToroAVO Syncro South America Ritmo
17Tatuaje L'Espirit De Verite 2013Oliveras All Stars Small Batch No. 5 Basso by Boutique Blends CigarsRoom 101/Caldwell Hit & Run ToroMy Father La Opulencia
18Aladino Maduro RothschildArchetype Sage Advice Toro by Ventura Cigar CompanyProtocol Probable Cause LanceroTatuaje Reserva J21 Broadleaf
19Tatuaje Reserva J21 BroadleafWarped Maestro del Tiempo 5712Winston Churchill Late Hour ToroNomad Fin De Los Mundos
20Viaje Atlantic 20th Anniversary WLP 20th Limited Edition ToroSouthern Draw Rose of Sharon ToroTatuaje Skinny Jason CazadoresDavidoff Master Selection 2008
21Montecristo 80 AniversarioDiamond Crown Black Diamond Emerald by J.C. Newman Cigar Co.Joya de Nicaragua Gran Reserva BelicosoCamacho Liberty 2017
22The Wise Man Maduro Corona GordaSerino Royale Medio Robusto GordoUndercrown Sungrown CoronaJoya de Nicaragua Antano Gran Reserva
23Fratello Navetta AtlantisQuesada Reserva Privada Barber-Pole RobustoGurkha Master Select 2017 ToroSouthern Draw Jacobs Ladder
24Fratello Oro CoronaDavid P. Ehrich Tremont Toro by MLB Cigar VenturesPatina Connecticut RobustoL'Atelier Identité No. 2
25Tatuaje La Verite 2013Protocol Themis Toro by Cubariqueno Cigar CompanyHoyo La Amistad Silver RobustoSerino Wayfarer
26N/ABlack Works Studio Sindustry ToroN/AN/A
27Rancho Luna Maduro Robusto by JRE Tobacco Company
28Southern Draw Jacobs Ladder Robusto
29E.P. Carrillo Original Rebel Rebellious 54
30Torano Vault E-021 Robusto



c.gar loves all things cigar-related. He typically falls in love with cigars that are discontinued shortly thereafter. His first cigar was a Swisher Sweet with a wood tip. Sadly, these are still in production.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *