2017 Cigar of the Year-A Compendium of Magazine Ratings

Below is a table with a list of the 2017 Cigar of the Year selections by various cigar magazines. While we don’t review cigars except for our own single Cigar of the Year published in January of each year, we certainly keep track of the selections. See below and enjoy. You can sort by cigar name, ranking, etc. to do your own comparison of the cigars selected by various sources.

o

RankingCigar Aficionado Top 25 Best Cigars of the YearCigar Journal Top 25 Cigars of the YearCigar Snob Top 25 Cigars of 2017Cigar Aficionado Best Buys of 2017
1Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Eye of the SharkMy Father The Judge Grand RobustoPlasencia Alma FuerteJoya Black Nocturno
2Padron Serie 1926 No. 2 (Natural)Perdomo Bourbon Barrel Aged Epicure ConnecticutCasa Fernandez Miami Aniversario Serie 2015Fonseca Nicaragua Petit Corona
3Oliva Serie V BelicosoDavidoff Winston Churchill Late Hour ChurchillFuente Fuente OpusX Angel's SharePadron Londres
4Bolivar Belicoso FinoPadron 1964 Anniversary Series Presidente Maduro ATTatuaje TAA 2016Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
5Alec Bradley Tempus Natural CenturiaRomeo Y Julieta Edicion Limitada 2016 CapuletosAJ Fernandez Enclave BroadleafFonseca Nicaragua Toro
6Ashton Symmetry BelicosoLa Flor Dominicana Andalusian BullOliva Serie V MelanioH. Upmann Vintage Cameroon Corona
7My Father The Judge Grand RobustoRocky Patel Fifty-Five RobustoHerrera EsteliOliva Serie O No. 4
8Guardian of the Farm Apollo Seleccion de WarpedPlasencia Alma Fuerte Generacion VPadron 1926 SerieVilliger 1888 Corona
9Plasencia Alma Fuerte Generacion VEiroa The First 20 54x6Villiger San'Doro ColoradoA. Flores Gran Reserva 1975 Half Corona
10Villiger La Flor de Ynclan RobustoBolivar Tesoro ER 2016 5TA AvenidaMy Father The JudgeArturo Fuente Cuban Corona
11Partagas LusitaniaA.J. Hernandez New World Puro Especial RobustoHamlet 25th YearArturo Fuente Chateau Fuente Sun Grown
12New World Puro Especial ToroJoya Black Doble RobustoCamacho Nicaragua Barrel-AgedAsylum Premium 44x4
13Archetype Axis Mundi ToroMonte by Montecristo AJ Fernandez ToroMonte by Montecristo AJ FernandezCasa Magna Colorado Pikito
14601 Red Label Habano TorpedoLa Galera Maduro El LectorSindicato Miami EditionEl Galan Semilla Cubana Habano Churchill
15Romeo Y Julieta Aging Room Small Batch F25 CantaorJuan Lopez Eminentes ER 2016 SuizaSan Isidro by HVCLa Aroma de Cuba Corona
16Rocky Patel Vintage 2003 Cameroon ChurchillFlor De Selva Coleccion Aniversario No 20 EgoistaCAO Amazon AnacondaLa Aurora 1903 Cameroon Robusto
17C.L.E. Prieto 50x52012 By Oscar Corojo ToroMurcielagoLast Call Maduro by A.J. Fernandez Pequenas
18E.P. Carrillo Dusk SolidosDon Kiki Platinum Label Limited Selection GrandeLa Flor Dominicana Double LigeroPunch Elite EMS
19Romeo Y Julieta Short ChurchillVegafina Fortaleza 2 Rum Barrel Aged SalomonDones Nieves SentimientoPunch Gran Puro Nicaragua
20Macanudo Inspirado Orange ChurchillBalmoral Anejo XO Torpedo MK52Winston Churchill The Late Hour7-20-4 Factory 57 Dog Walker
21Regius Exclusivo U.S.A. Pressed Perfecto1502 XO ChurchillSobremesaCAO Brazilia Corcovado
22Joya Black NocturnoMicallef Reserva Limitada Privada ChurchillUndercrown Sun GrownDon Diego Lonsdale
23La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero LanceroAging Room Solera Corojo FantasticoLa Galera 1936 Box-PressedLa Aurora 1495 15 Minute Break
24Tatuaje Cabinet NoellasMBombay Gaaja TorpedoLa Aurora Preferidos BroadleafLa Aurora 1903 Cameroon Churchill
25Undercrown ChurchillEl Galan Reserva Especial Connecticut AirosoCornelius & Anthony - CorneliusLast Call Maduro by A.J. Fernandez Chiquitas
26N/AN/AN/ATatuaje Havana VI Verocu No. 5
27VegaFina Nicaragua Corona
28Viva Republica Advanced Warfare

c.gar

c.gar

c.gar loves all things cigar-related. He typically falls in love with cigars that are discontinued shortly thereafter. His first cigar was a Swisher Sweet with a wood tip. Sadly, these are still in production.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *